I recently got the following comment on my blog (it’s still sitting in moderation, it’s not viewable to the public for reasons I’m sure will become quite clear when you read it). I was going to just ignore it…but you know, I can’t. Here’s the comment left by someone named “Hazel”:
“Uh, hey, since you said you’re sooo out of the harry potter craze in a recent entry, perhaps you could take down the sorting hat quiz that you blatantly stole from my friend’s website, word for word? Cause, it’s, like, her original work, and an author’s works are automatically protected by copyright, even if they don’t register them, and she has logs proving when her quiz was posted to her website. Or would you prefer to be a plagiarizing c*** for the rest of your life? Or at least, until she sues you? Inquiring minds want to know.”
Note: I edited out the rude word she called me…because, you know, who needs that? I’m sure if you use your imagination you can figure it out.
Since “inquiring minds want to know”, I would like to address Miss Hazel and her accusations:
While I admire you for standing up for “your friend”, I think it would be wise for you to check out all the facts in this case first before you make accusations, jump to conclusions, and pretty much decide that I’ve done something wrong. So let me respond to each point you make one at a time.
1. “…since you said you’re sooo out of the harry potter craze in a recent entry…” It’s true, I am “out of the Harry Potter craze” but what does that have to do with anything? I am still a fan, just not so wild about it as I was before, but that doesn’t mean I automatically have to strike everything from my website that I made that happens to be Harry Potter related.
2. “…perhaps you could take down the sorting hat quiz that you blatantly stole from my friend’s website, word for word?” You mean this quiz? Funny…I distinctly remember making that quiz from scratch without copying anything from anyone. I do admit (of course) to borrowing the ideas from Ms. J.K. Rowling and acknowledge that the underlying idea of the Hogwarts houses, classes, etc. belong to her. But the quiz text, all of the images, and the coding of that page were written and created by me and me alone. No, I won’t take it down.
3. “…she has logs proving when her quiz was posted to her website…” I don’t know who “your friend” is, but I can take a guess. On the same day (3/10/09) I received your comment on my blog I also just happened to receive an email sent through my website contact form accusing me of the same thing you are accusing me of and quite kindly pointed me in the direction of the website NextIncantation.com. I can only assume you sent that email, I find it highly unlikely I would get two accusations on the same day about the same thing (when I’ve never been accused of it before) and it not being connected.
I did some digging around on NextIncantation.com and found this page. Wow, you are right! It’s exactly the same…word for word. Imagine that. I took note of the date that sorting hat quiz was posted: March 08, 2008. I can only assume these are the logs you are referring to since you did not do me the courtesy of pointing out where I might find any logs in your original accusation. That’s fine, and because I’m nice and willing to give someone the benefit of the doubt, let’s just pretend for a minute that maybe the owner and administrator of NextIncantation.com had the quiz posted at an earlier date on her website in a different location. Okay…but I wish to point out that after doing a little research on the “Who Is” database I discovered that the website NextIncantation.com was first created on June 10, 2006. Let’s just say, to make this easy, that “your friend”, the owner and maintainer of NextIncantation.com (let’s call her “Lycanth” for fun) posted her quiz on that date.
Next, I would invite you to again visit my own quiz and take a few things into consideration. If you right click on that page with your mouse (in any browser besides Internet Explorer…I use a right click prevention code that only works with IE, but try it with Firefox), then select “View Page Info”. Please carefully read the information provided in that nice little window. It quite clearly states that my quiz page was last modified on June 26, 2002.
That is nearly FOUR FULL YEARS before NextIncantation.com was even in existence.
4. “…an author’s works are automatically protected by copyright…” Then I don’t have anything to worry about since I am the author. Thank you for pointing out my rights.
5. “…would you prefer to be a plagiarizing c*** for the rest of your life?” Do I really need to respond to that amazingly rude comment?
6. “Or at least, until she sues you?” This especially amuses me. Do you know how much seeking legal litigation costs? Do you realize how much time that would take? Excuse me for not taking this threat seriously, I highly doubt “your friend” would waste her time…especially since I’m sure she knows who the real plagiarizer is in this case…and it’s not me.
Speaking of “your friend”, why don’t you ask her how she came up with her Sorting Hat quiz yourself? Better yet, why don’t you invite her to come and read this blog post of mine and tell you what she thinks about what I have to say? I’d be very interested in her thoughts about all of this. I would welcome a conversation with “Lycanth”, the supposed owner and maintainer of NextIncantation.com…and creator of a Sorting Hat quiz that looks suspiciously like one I made almost seven years ago. You know, I’m a nice person. If she had come to me and asked if she could use it I might have said yes. People have asked me permission to use things I made in the past and I’m usually very open to sharing with those willing to give me credit where credit is due. In a way, I’m flattered she felt the need to use my quiz word for word, it means it’s a good quiz (and it should be given the time, energy, and research I put into writing it). However, I don’t like being taken advantage of and being left open for people’s friends to throw their unfounded accusations at. You might want to advise “your friend” that it would be in her best interest to either ask me for permission to use my quiz, with the promise of giving me credit and a link to the original material, or take it down.
It’s also interesting to note, Hazel, that I would have never known of the existence of NextIncantation.com or the Sorting Hat quiz there if it hadn’t been for you pointing it out to me. Up until your comment and subsequent email, I would have been none the wiser that anyone was using my quiz and claiming as their own. Thank you for bringing this to my attention. I’m sure “your friend” will thank you as well.